Prints failing with new FEP sheet

My previous fep sheet cracked while I was moving so I replaced it with a new one. Made sure to remove the protective film, use the bottle cap method for tightness, and made sure to avoid installing screws in a circle pattern.

I ran the test print and it came out perfectly. So I tried out another model that previously worked but this time it failed (see photo).

I looked into a bunch of solutions, and the only one I haven't tried is the PTFE lubricant. I'm not sure if that's the only solution or if there's something else I'm completely missing.

I'm out of ideas to make this printer work and I wanted to check if there's a fix I missed before spending money on the lubricant.