Umass Amherst or Mount Holyoke College? Help be choose

Before you say the two are not comparable, hear me out.

I have been planning on commuting to college for most of my high school years. I live about 25-30 minutes way from umass so it was my top choice. After receiving all my admission decisions, I am now between umass and mhc. Since my fafsa signature did not go through, I am unable to see my financial aid offer from umass, however, Mount Holyoke has already sent me their package. After grants and scholarships, my price was around $12k. I think this is a very good deal considering it is a private college.

But, if I go to mhc I will most likely live on campus. This is not a deal breaker, but definitely something that I wasn’t planning on doing. I’m generally a very introverted person, so the mhc campus would seem like a better fit but idk

Decision day is coming up really soon and I need to hear someone’s honest opinion on what I should do.