Why are gap years so frowned upon?
Benefits include:
Time to gain work experience and earn money
Time to knock out gen eds at CC
Time for personal major related projects
Time for volunteering and service
Improved GPA (only for those leaning on an upward trend due to being able to submit full senior year grades)
Time to improve test scores
Get to EA pretty much everywhere you apply
Time to specialize and really think about what you want to do in college
Do that one thing you really wanted to do
Drawbacks include:
Loss of study skills
Loss of motivation
Unforeseen events (relationship, pregnancy, etc)
Rooting down too soon (financing a car, incurring loan debt, etc)
Not using it productively (gooning in your parents basement)
I think a lot of this is selection bias as the people who are weaker students = unsure about college = takes gap year = gets comfortable = not ending up going. I think a lot of it is about knowing yourself. If you are a strong student and are taking a gap for any of the benefits listed I say go for it IMO. From what I heard it will likely be a positive for ones application if used well.