How can I request original parts? Progressive is offering remanufactured parts for the repair of my vehicle, but I'd prefer new, original parts instead.

A few days ago all four wheels were stolen from my car. Additionally, the car was damaged; the lower part of the vehicle was bent, and other parts were damaged. My insurance company sent me an estimate repair document where the wheels are marked as remanufactured, but I do not agree with this. Since my car has only 6,500 miles on it and my alloy wheels were in brand-new condition, can I request them to put original wheels on my vehicle? What should I do in this situation?