I need expert opinion on which account to keep.

A little more than a week ago, I lost my account and couldn't retrieve it through customer support because I didn't know the accounts UID number. Well, I found the number by finding my profile on a hero rating, but I haven't contacted support yet.

The account I lost had an a1 Hatssut and a pretty far along Idril, this new account is a little more further along in progression and has an a1 Valkyra, Lyra, Eona and a maxed out Idril.

My gut is telling me just stick with the new account, but damn part of me fears I'll never get a Hatssut again as a f2p player.

Any thoughts which account I should keep?