Would you support this new economic model?

Two tiered Capitalism. Which would you pick?

Tier one you are given everything you need to live by the government. Free food, free housing, free Internet, free cell phones, free healthcare, no insurance of any kind required, free public services, even your grass is cut. No job required. But no luxuries are permitted. No ownership is permitted. There is no income, there is no taxes. There is no cash or credit cards. You do what you want with your time. Marriage sanctioned under the government is abolished. People in tier one do not vote as there is no reason. You can leave Tier one with nothing and go to Tier 2 with nothing at anytime.

Tier two, you work or own businesses and your ceiling is unlimited. Ambition thrives. Competition thrives. You own private property and accumulate wealth. Nothing is free like in tier one. Taxes are flat for everyone and there are no deductions. All money is digital. You can fail tier 2 and go back to tier 1 by giving up everything at any time.