Bleacher Report Gives 2024 Panthers D+

https://bleacherreport.com/articles/10152187-realistic-grades-for-every-nfl-teams-2024-season

Maurice Moton evaluated the league and puts the 2024 Panthers near the bottom citing terrible defense, developing QB, and no strengths

I'd say C- is more appropriate.

Further, PFF gave Young a 74.4 even after his early season struggles. If Young puts a full season together like he played in the second half of 2024, we could easily see him become a top 20-15 QB.

His average passer rating over his last 8 games was 91.6. That's good for middle of the pack for 2024. With a better defense and development from his young pass catchers, we could see him improve even further and possibly a winning season in 2025. Maybe we'll see even better than that with a few surprises here and there.